
I liked what they tried to do with this film, and that was embody the 1987 experience, and they did achieve that, but it failed for me because it was too long and too predictable. I feel I was misinformed about the comedic value this film was supposed to deliver. It felt more like a coming of age, sappy sort of story and I was prepared for more of a comedy, due to the misleading marketing and trailer. While there were a few funny scenes, there weren't enough to hold my interest, and therefore it felt way too long. I found myself wanting it to end far earlier than it did. I knew how it would end from the very beginning. I was happy that they used the Replacements for music, and that made me momentarily happy. It reads more like a television show, than a full length feature. I think this movie was supposed to be "cooler" than it actually is. The trailer features the more comedic scenes, and Violent Femmes music,which wasn't even in the movie, but it was boring! Also, the lead character, James, played by Jesse Eisenberg,was an exact replica of Jesse's character in his last film, Roger Dodger; a virginal, likable geek who winds up being ok just the way he is. I have seen it all before. The mix of the telltale comedic actors such as, Bill Hader and Kristen Wiig, of Saturday Night Live fame within a drama confused me. I thought I was going to see a hilarious film when actually I was force fed a drama about Em Lewin, played by Kristen Stewart who had a pension for picking all the wrong men until she met James, and James, a uncomfortable virgin who finally meets his match. It just didn't have "it" for me. I was greatly surprised by the reemergence of Martin Starr, of Freaks and Geeks fame, who plays Joel. I am a huge Freaks and Geeks fan! Eh, I was just not so excited about this story. I see where they tried to go with the execution, but somehow didn't hit that mark. Ryan Reynolds character didn't suit him either....All star cast but no go... save it for a rental.
I give it a 3 out of 10.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gtVnRAY5LQE

















